Defining “Low GWP”

written by Pavel Makhnatch (under supervision of Rahmatollah Khodabandeh and Björn Palm)

Published Nov 04, 2013

As many refrigerants are strong greenhouse gases, the use of the refrigerants with low global warming potential (GWP) is seen as a way to minimize the effect of the refrigeration systems on the global warming. However, how low GWP value should the low GWP refrigerant have?

Refrigerants differ greatly in terms of their global warming potential. Some refrigerants have very low GWP values of from 0 to 7 (Ammonia, CO2, R290, R1234yf), some a bit higher (R152a, R32). There are also refrigerants with greater GWP values of, for instance 1430 (R134a) and 2088 (R410A). Which of the above listed are “low GWP” refrigerants?

150 as an indicative GWP value for “low GWP”

More than 6 years ago EU has come out with the Directive, which set the limit on GWP value of refrigerant to be used in mobile air conditioning (MAC) systems [1] and thus promoted the use of the refrigerants with low GWP. Although no definition of “low GWP refrigerant” is given by the Directive, it has become publically accepted that “low GWP refrigerants” are those with GWP of no greater than 150. This limit allows one to choose from a number of potential refrigerants, including natural CO2, new synthetic R1234yf and conventional R152a, which seemed to be the one that dictated the final value of 150. New F-gas Regulation proposal is using the threshold GWP value of 150 in some parts of the regulation as well [2].

The industry reacted to new legislations by increased development in area of low GWP refrigerants: both for MAC systems and for other refrigeration systems. While it was possible to find suitable low GWP replacement for R134a, for other common refrigerants like R410A and R404A alternatives with GWP of lower than 150 by far could not be easily found (apart from natural refrigerants CO2 and HCs, which will then require significant system redesign to be used), as it is indicated at the Figure 1 [3]. This indicates that the GWP of 150 is probably not a perfect threshold value for refrigerants to be referred as “low GWP” ones.

Figure 1 - Low GWP alternatives to common refrigerants [3]

“Low” or “very low”

The simple Google search on “Low GWP refrigerants” gives us around a hundred thousand results. While the term is widely used today, the strong interest to low GWP refrigerants arose just a few years ago. At the beginning, the discussion around this topic seemed to be held mainly by the main chemical production companies: researchers from Daikin discussed R32 as a promising “low GWP refrigerant” in the air conditioning field [4], their colleagues from Honeywell presented an “Update on an ultra-low GWP refrigerant” use [5], DuPont presented its refrigerant with “very low GWP” [6]. Note the use of the ultra-low, very low and low terms during that time.

The fact that no clear definitions of “low GWP” and “high GWP” are available was indicated by United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) in its previous progress report [7]. There it was discussed, that the terms themselves are of comparative nature, and therefore needs to be related to some mean GWP value. The medium value for a range of refrigerants was estimated to be slightly greater than 2000 and a classification, as presented at Figure 2, has been suggested. This classification did not become standard by this time and UNEP itself is mostly using three comparative terms – “low”, “medium” and “high” GWP - in its new report [8].

Figure 2 – GWP classification of greenhouse gases, proposal [7]

“Medium” GWP refrigerants would reduce confusion

The recent Ecodesign Regulation proposal have raised the bar for the low GWP value by proposing lower minimum efficiency requirement for a selected equipment which uses refrigerants with GWP 675 or less [9]. “The GWP threshold of 675 kg CO2 eq. is proposed in the preparatory study on air conditioning. It originates from the GWP of the refrigerant R-32. Of the low GWP refrigerants, R-32 is the one with the highest GWP. It could become an interesting alternative to R-410A and R-407C, since it has a low GWP and a possible performance increase”, explains the European Commission [10].

Because of the absence of an agreement in definition of “low GWP” term, the confusion is often arise when dealing with new environmentally friendly refrigerants. Perhaps, it would be easier to level the refrigerants if low/high GWP range would be clearly defined and, perhaps, extended to include medium GWP refrigerant range.

Works Cited

[1]

European Parliament, "Directive 2006/40/EC of the European Parliament and of the council," Official Journal of the European Union, 2006.

[2]

European Commission, "Proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the council on fluorinated greenhouse gases," Brussels, 2012.

[3]

K. Amrane, Overview of AHRI Research on Low-GWP Refrigerants, 2013.

[4]

R. Yajima, K. Kita, S. Taira and N. Domyo, "R32 as a solution for energy conservation and low emission," in International Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Conference, Purdue, 2000.

[5]

M. Spatz, "Update on an ultra-low GWP refrigerant for mobile air conditioning applications," Alternative Refrigerant Systems Symposium, 2006.

[6]

Green Car Congress, "DuPont Refrigerants Unveils First DP-1 Refrigerant Test Car in Germany," 29 Nov 2006. [Online]. Available: http://www.greencarcongress.com/2006/11/dupont_refriger.html.

[7]

UNEP, TEAP 2010 progress report. Volume 1., 2010.

[8]

UNEP, "Report of the technology and economic assessment panel. Volume 1.," 2013.

[9]

European Commission, draft Ecodesign Regulation: working document on possible requirements for air heating products, cooling products and high temperature process chillers, 2013.

[10]

European Commission, Explanatory Notes: working documents on possible requirements for air heating products, cooling products and high temperature process chillers, 2013.

Page responsible:bpalm@energy.kth.se
Belongs to: Department of Energy Technology
Last changed: Nov 04, 2013

News

Title Date
Developments on the refrigerant front during the past year Jan 03, 2019
Low GWP refrigerants: previous and ongoing projects Dec 03, 2018
Environmentally friendly refrigeration systems are needed to mitigate the climate change Sep 28, 2018
Natural refrigerants in focus of the Gustav Lorentzen conference Aug 14, 2018
Research focused on safe use of combustible refrigerants Jul 11, 2018
Highlights from the conference on cold chain and refrigeration exhibition in China Apr 30, 2018
The effects of the F-Gas Regulation concern the heat pump industry Apr 30, 2018
New F-gas regulation quota is in place. Are we on track to meet it? Feb 08, 2018
This happened in refrigerant development during the past year Feb 07, 2018
F-gases: do we know what they are? Feb 07, 2018
Emissions of fluorinated gases and their emission reduction Jan 09, 2018
Ten non-flammable alternatives to R404A Aug 24, 2017
Refrigerants: current developments Aug 22, 2017
The future of R404A and other refrigerants with high GWP values as prices rise Aug 09, 2017
Refrigerants: what to expect in the future Jun 19, 2017
Standards and their role in refrigerants development Feb 07, 2017
This happened in refrigerant development during the past year Jan 27, 2017
Environmentally friendly refrigerants of the future Jan 27, 2017
An option to replace R404A in small refrigeration systems Nov 14, 2016
Highlights form the Gustav Lorentzen conference on natural fluids. Nov 13, 2016
The opportunities and challenges of R152a. Part 2. Nov 12, 2016
The opportunities and challenges of R152a. Part 1. Nov 12, 2016
Sources of refrigerant property data Mar 23, 2016
A year in low GWP refrigerants development Mar 18, 2016
Reducing environmental impact of refrigeration technology Feb 29, 2016
The potential dangers of TFA Nov 01, 2015
Key news in low GWP refrigerants developments Nov 01, 2015
HFO refrigerants explained Oct 31, 2015
Understanding refrigerant flammability Jun 23, 2015
New opportunities for R32 Jun 21, 2015
A guide to F-gas regulation guides Apr 21, 2015
In short about R1234ze Apr 21, 2015
Replacements for R404A Oct 22, 2014
R1336mzz-Z - new generation nonflammable low GWP refrigerant Sep 21, 2014
Low GWP refrigerants for high temperature heat pumps Sep 21, 2014
Safety of new low GWP refrigerants Sep 05, 2014
Can global temperature change potential replace GWP in upcoming regulations? Apr 16, 2014
Quantifying global warming potential Apr 23, 2014
New F-gas Directive, one step closer to the final decision! Feb 02, 2014
A year in new low GWP refrigerants development Feb 02, 2014
Defining “Low GWP” Nov 04, 2013
Which refrigerant replaces next R410A? Nov 03, 2013
New opportunities for natural refrigerants Oct 31, 2013
Uncertain future of fluorinated refrigerants Oct 29, 2013
European Commission’s feedback on MAC Directive implementation issues Oct 28, 2013
R-1234yf to be used in MAC systems, despite safety concerns Oct 26, 2013
Environmental metrics for evaluating refrigeration systems operation Oct 25, 2013
Low GWP alternative refrigerants in heat pumps Oct 25, 2013
Mercedes-Benz wishes to continue using the tried-and-tested R-134a refrigerant in passenger cars Sep 28, 2012
Stability and compatibility of HFOs Aug 07, 2012
Counterfeit refrigerants are on the rise Jul 16, 2012
European Commission sets new deadline: manufacturers may continue to use old refrigerants May 18, 2012
Sweden accelerates the transition towards HFC alternatives May 10, 2012
Refrigerant effect on system performance May 08, 2012
Welcome Mar 30, 2012