| Assessment criteria |
0 pt |
2-4 pts |
4-6 pts |
6-8 pts |
| Fail |
Poor |
Good |
Excellent |
| 1. Report structure-basic structure includes introduction, method, results and discussions, and conclusions. Other report structures may also be used provided that the authors could clearly elaborate their viewpoints. |
The report lacks clear structure and there is significant missing information. |
The report follows a clear structure, but contains too much or too little information which makes the report difficult to read. |
The structure is clear and logical, but may have some minor problems that could confuse an audience, such as out-of-order information or missing sections. |
The structure is clear and logical. It follows normal scientific conventions and the audience can understand the format easily. It is appropriate for the scientific content you will deliver. |
| 2. Language and formatting |
The report is not within page limit and the language is difficult to read. |
The language is difficult to read and the report suffers from major formatting issues such as a lack of paragraphing, missing page numbers, inconsistent citation/reference styles, missing captions for figures or tables…etc. |
The language is easy to read. The report is within the page limit. However, there are some minor formatting issues with the headings, main body text, tables, figures, captions, page numbers, or citations. |
The language is fluent and easy to read. All sections of the report are clearly labeled and formatted. All pages contain a page number. The report is within the page limit. All tables and figures are referred to in the main body text. There is a good balance between text, figures, and tables for illustration of ideas. Both qualitative descriptions and numerical data are included in the report to showcase one's stance. There is no missing citations and the styles for citation and bibliography are consistent and correct. |
| 3. Report content |
The author(s) gathers information from only 1-3 scientific articles and the scope of the work is very limited, with no connection with the concepts of a circular economy. |
The report includes information from 3-9 scientific articles and there is a lack of a holistic overview of the topic and connection with the concepts of circular economy. |
The report includes information from minimally 10 scientific articles. The report showcases that the author(s) have a good overview of the subject but lacks detailed comprehension of certain aspects (e.g. status-quo, challenges, future prospects). The link bewteen the present study and the concepts of a circular economy is also not particularly clear. |
The report includes information from minimally 10 scientific articles. The report showcases that the author(s) have a good understanding about the current status, existing solutions, challenges of the problem studied and makes reference to the concepts of a circular economy. |
| 4. Creativity and originality |
The report merely states the findings from different reference sources and does not include any comparison, analyses, or self reflection on the subject. |
The report assimilates finding across different references using only text and there is a lack of the authors' own analyses and criticism of the subject studied. |
The report assimilates finding across different references using text/tables/figures and propose solution(s) to the problem(s) studied but falls short of a critical analyses of the topic and the methods used by the previous researchers. |
The report assimilates finding across different references using tables/figures, identifies the strengths and shortcomings of different studies, critically analyzes the topic, and propose solution(s) to the problem(s) and suggests areas for future work. |
| 5. Use of artificial intelligence (AI) must be stated clearly at the beginning of the report, just below the names of the authors |
Does not include a statement regarding the use of AI, or uses AI to write the whole report. |
Uses AI for literature search and for creating some parts of the body text (including tables and excluding figures). |
Uses AI for literature search and for the creation of report structure. |
No use of AI at all, or only uses AI for generating keywords for literature search, polishing of written text, and for generation of figures. |